Choosing the best cooler can make or break a weekend camping trip. Thawed out meat on your first day of a several day camping trip can get messy! Food poisoning while in the woods is not pleasant. Plan ahead, and get into the right cooler for your needs.
With so many brands claiming to be the “best,” it’s easy to get overwhelmed. In this head-to-head showdown, We’ll break down Yeti, Coleman, Igloo, and Pelican coolers to help you pick the perfect one for your needs—plus, I’ll share Amazon product links to the best selling and trusted models that deliver on performance. Let’s find you the Best Cooler so you can really Chill Out this summer!
Define Your Needs and Priorities
Before comparing brands, you first need to determine what type of adventure you are seeking. Are you looking at short term or long term stays. What are your needs? Are you trying to keep burgers frozen, or beverages frosty? Are you going to be in full sun, or is there some shade nearby?
Here are a few more probing questions to ask yourself:
- Ice Retention: How long do you need ice to last? (3 days vs. 7 days?)
- Durability: Will it survive rocky trails or bear encounters?
- Portability: Are you car camping or hiking to your site?
- Budget: Premium coolers $300+, or mid line $100-300 or affordable<$100?
Pro Tip: Use block ice and pre-chill your cooler for max efficiency!
Best Cooler Battle of the Brands – Breakdown
1. Yeti Coolers
Best Cooler For: Extreme conditions and lifelong durability.
- Top Pick: Yeti Tundra 45 (Hard Cooler)
- Pros:
- Keeps ice frozen for 5-7 days (tested in 90°F+ heat).
- Bear-resistant certification (ideal for Canadian backcountry).
- Nearly indestructible rotomolded construction.
- Cons:
- Heavy (23 lbs empty).
- Premium price tag.
- Verdict: A splurge for serious campers who camp often.
- Pros:
2. Coleman Coolers
Best Cooler For: Budget-friendly car camping.
- Top Pick: Coleman Xtreme 70-Quart
- Pros:
- Affordable (80−80−120).
- Lightweight and easy to haul.
- Holds ice for 3-4 days in mild temps.
- Cons:
- Hinges/latches can crack over time.
- Struggles in extreme heat.
- Verdict: Reliable for casual weekenders on a budget.
- Pros:
3. Igloo Coolers
Best Cooler For: Balance of price and performance.
- Top Pick: Igloo BMX 52-Quart
- Pros:
- Great ice retention (4-5 days).
- Features like cup holders and tie-down slots.
- Affordable.
- Cons:
- Less rugged than Yeti/Pelican.
- Thin insulation in very hot weather.
- Verdict: Ideal for most weekend trips (no extreme conditions).
- Pros:
4. Pelican Coolers
Best Cooler For: Arctic expeditions and overlanding.
- Top Pick: Pelican Elite 50-Quart
- Pros:
- 7+ days of ice retention (outperforms Yeti in some tests).
- Lifetime warranty (covers bear damage!).
- Non-slip feet and stainless steel latches.
- Cons:
- Bulky and heavy (26 lbs empty).
- Pricier than Yeti.
- Verdict: The ultimate cooler for harsh, remote adventures.
- Pros:
What is the Best Cooler? The Final Verdict
- 🏆 Best Overall: Igloo BMX 52-Quart
- Why? It’s half the price of Yeti/Pelican but keeps ice frozen for 4-5 days—perfect for 95% of weekend trips. GearFinder suggests this is the best cooler for ice retention.
- 🥇 Premium Pick: Yeti Tundra 45
- Worth it if you camp monthly or need bear-proof security.
- 💸 Budget Win: Coleman Xtreme 70-Quart
- A no-brainer for occasional car campers.
- ❄️ Extreme Conditions: Pelican Elite 50-Quart
- Built for -40°C winters or grizzly territory.
Pro Upgrades for Your Cooler
- Yeti Ice Pack: Reusable ice substitute that lasts longer.
Why Buy Now?
Summer camping gear sells out fast! Lock in your cooler early to test it on shorter spring trips before summer 2025.
Ready to Upgrade?
Tap the affiliate links above to shop GearFinders top picks on Amazon—each cooler rates high on the review charts and are trusted by outdoor pros. Tag GearFinder Canada in your camping pics, and let’s make your next trip the coolest one yet!
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links.
Check out some of our other highly rated and recommended Camping Gear!
